deviant art

Deviant Login Shop  Join deviantART for FREE Take the Tour
[x]
more ▶

Featured in Groups:

Details

September 24, 2012
Link
Thumb

Statistics

Comments: 43
Favourites: 10 [who?]

Views: 11,725 (0 today)
[x]
Minecraft Tournaments
When I was in London, I met a lot of people. One of the helpers at the MCM convention runs a website known as Skyrie.net. A gaming website. Since we're both minecraft fans, we've been trying to start a project together for quite some time.

I can't go into more details just yet, but I can tell you now that we've got a tentative plan for a monthly tournament contest. The idea would be that over on Skyrie.net we'd have a notification for the time and server for a PVP match each week. At the end of the week we'd all log on and compete against each other in various minecraft PVP maps (such as "the walls" or the abundant "survival games," etc). At the end of the month, winners would be given a prize, which most likely will be an indi steam game or something.

The details are, naturally, still being fleshed out. Me and the host of the maps would be participating as contestants (though obviously we can't win any prizes) as a means to record the matches and post them to YouTube for everyone who couldn't make it in to watch.

Like I said, we're working on it, but I gotta say I'm really excited about this idea. I'll give you guys more info as we figure it out and hopefully we can have our first tournament pretty soon.

Critiques Journal
A few days ago I made a journal encouraging everyone who commented to go through and give feedback and critiques to anyone who requested it. It was... moderately successful. Some people got lots of critiques, some people got nothing. I've been thinking about this idea and I would like to continue it again, but maybe with a bit more of a focus.

So here's the new idea. Sometime later this week I'll make another journal, asking for people to post (at max) 2 deviations they want feedback on. Since this will be an ongoing thing, there will be a cap of the first 40 people to comment being the max per journal as a way of keeping things from getting out of hand. To make things even simpler, I just want the : thumb : link from the deviations themselves (which can be found on the right hand side underneath the deviation). I'll then copy/paste those all into the next journal, allowing people to just click on the deviations themselves rather than having to hunt down names. I won't even list user names, just display the deviations.

I think that will help people get more specific feedback, and keep things simple and accessible. Please don't post any now, I'm not ready for them just yet. But... What do you guys think, though? Do you think this will work better?
  • Mood: Optimism
  • Listening to: Yogscast Tekkit Series
  • Reading: tumblr
  • Watching: Doctor Who
  • Playing: Minecraft: Tekkit
  • Eating: Jaffa Cakes
  • Drinking: English Breakfast Tea
Add a Comment:
 
love 0 0 joy 1 1 wow 0 0 mad 0 0 sad 0 0 fear 0 0 neutral 0 0
:iconvickyviolet:
~VickyViolet Sep 26, 2012  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
I do like the idea of thumbnails only. :)
Reply
:icondreamcloud123:
~dreamcloud123 Sep 26, 2012  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
Definitely sounds more direct, which could help. Seems like it could work!
Reply
:iconpaladin343:
~Paladin343 Sep 25, 2012  Hobbyist General Artist
Question: Would writing be permitted?
Reply
:iconpentaro22:
~Pentaro22 Sep 25, 2012  Hobbyist Artist
Yay! Let's do it!!!! :iconyeahplz:
Reply
:iconnel-katz:
I guess.. It is a good idea! Hope to see it coming. :)
Reply
:iconsasheradesigns:
~SasheraDesigns Sep 25, 2012  Student Digital Artist
i think the new critique system could be a good idea, i mean the old one was nice but at the same time, having the deviations there in thumbnail form might prompt more interest from people, yknow like "oh that image looks really interesting! *click*"
Reply
:iconvoytess:
~Voytess Sep 24, 2012  Student General Artist
Minecraft PvP sounds interesting, but since I can hardly even deal with mobs (I can't face endermen even with invincible armour mods) I probably wouldn't be able to participate =p.

On the critique side, I'm worried that, while the idea is sound, people are going to look more at works they like and not at deviations that need the critique more. Feature journals where some of the work is traditional have shown this time and time again - when there is a murky photo rather than scan of a pencil drawing or a pencil drawing that isn't visually interesting in its contrast (which for beginners (who need critique the most) is always) they never get looked at as people jump right for the digital works or professional traditional stuff due to them being naturally higher in contrast and colourful. Perhaps don't show thumbnails and instead just have links (with subsections so it doesn't get confusing)?

Also, with the top 40 thing, would you feature the same people multiple times? I ask on behalf of my Australian bretheren who always miss these 'first x people to post' things that Americans host, and this applies to a lot of Asian countries too. Featuring different people each time would give them a chance.

All that being said, the fact you're even making an effort is admirable and no matter what you do some of the people who don't get enough publicity and feedback are going to get it, so don't feel bad if you can't please everyone :)
Reply
:iconkaszimera:
*Kaszimera Sep 24, 2012  Hobbyist Photographer
sounds good. but it might be hard for some to get in the special 40 list. so maybe, if you could...i dunno, keep track of who's posted a deviation already, to keep from the same people getting a critique? I dunno, sounds hard...Good luck with your idea though!
Reply
:iconmissannoyingtam:
~MissAnnoyingTAM Sep 24, 2012  Hobbyist Digital Artist
I think its a pretty reasonable idea for those critiques :)
Reply
:iconfastaanta1924:
~fastaanta1924 Sep 24, 2012  Hobbyist Digital Artist
That would help a lot with the critique, because it was more time consuming to click through their galleries... not very much, but still. xD

Just a question, but are you allowed to "reserve" spots, then put the deviant as a reply to your comment later?
Reply
Add a Comment: